ALEC in Michigan: Full Report w/ Executive Summary by Progress Michigan, Common Cause, & Michigan Citizen Action

Great timing for a follow up to the comments in this post. We were talking about the ALEC bill that was sponsored by Maureen Stapleton and celebrated by the Mackinac Center:

“If a teacher is rated as ineffective for three consecutive years, the district could fire the teacher.

“Parents are taxpayers,” said State Rep. Dave Agema, R-Grandville. “If they don’t want their kid being taught by an ineffective teacher, that’s their call. It’s all about choice. It comes down to parental choice and it also makes the teachers more accountable.”

ALEC is the shadow group behind the Republican caucus.

Here’s the press release from Progress Michigan, Common Cause, & Michigan Citizen Action. It hit the wire about a half-hour ago:


News from Progress Michigan, Common Cause & Michigan Citizen Action

Monday, August 13, 2012

CONTACT: Jessica Tramontana, 517-974-6302

New Report Showcases Corporate Drafting of Michigan Voter Suppression, Education & Health Care Bills

24 current lawmakers belong to shadowy corporate lobby group ALEC

LANSING – Citizens groups released a new report today showcasing the corporate drafting of multiple Michigan laws, including voter suppression, education, and health care legislation. The American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC) is a secretive “bill mill” that links state legislators with big corporate lobbyists, who draft model legislation that directly benefits their bottom lines at the expense of Michigan families. The report, ALEC Exposed in Michigan, highlights multiple bills that are clear cut-and-paste jobs from ALEC model legislation.

“Michigan citizens have a right to know who is writing our laws,” said Zack Pohl, Executive Director of Progress Michigan. “It’s time for Michigan legislators to cut ties with ALEC and focus on rebuilding our economy and strengthening the middle class.”

The report shows that at least 20 corporation-friendly bills recently introduced in the Michigan legislature closely echo ALEC model bills. House Bill 5221, which was introduced by Rep. Dave Agema (R-Grandville) and requires voters to provide proof of citizenship when registering to vote, is a blatant cut-and-paste job from ALEC’s “Taxpayer and Citizen Protection Act.”

“Michigan should be encouraging all eligible voters to have their say and cast a ballot, not making the process harder,” said Melanie McElroy, Executive Director of Common Cause Michigan. “Every eligible voter who wants to vote should not be turned away because of complicated and confusing rules. Unfortunately, that’s exactly what this ALEC model bill is intended to do – confuse voters and suppress the vote.”

In 2011, Rep. Tom McMillin (R-Rochester Hills) introduced “The Michigan Health Care Freedom Act,” which allows Michigan to opt out of the Affordable Care Act. Much of the language of HB 4050 is the same or very similar to ALEC’s “Freedom of Choice in Health Care Act.”

“This ALEC model bill is bad medicine for Michigan,” said Linda Teeter, Executive Director of Progress Michigan. “We need our elected officials to focus on protecting the health of Michigan citizens, not the profits of big corporations and CEOs. It’s time for lawmakers to follow the GM’s lead and drop their ALEC memberships once and for all.”

Following public pressure from citizens groups, General Motors officially cut ties with ALEC last month. Since this spring, 32 corporations and 4 non-profits have publicly announced that they are cutting ties with ALEC due to the organization’s support for Voter ID and so-called “Stand Your Ground” gun laws.

Currently, 24 Michigan lawmakers have known ties to ALEC, including 13 committee chairs. The list of current Representatives includes: Dave Agema, Jud Gilbert, Gail Haines, Ken Horn, Eileen Kowall, Ken Kurtz, Matt Lori, Pete Lund, Tom McMillin, Aric Nesbitt, Amanda Price & Mike Shirkey. The list of Senators includes: Darwin Booher, Bruce Caswell, Mike Green, Geoff Hansen, Dave Hildenbrand, Rick Jones, Mike Kowall, Arlan Meekhoff, John Moolenaar, Mike Nofs, David Robertson & Tonya Schuitmaker.

An Executive Summary of the report can be viewed here:

The full report may be viewed here:

There are no cover bands in the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame. Follow me on Twitter - @christinebarry
View all posts by Christine   
Christine Website   


  1. Hector Solon says:

    This a great, but just a start on ALEC in Michigan.

    ALEC influence in Michigan goes long and deep, through the Mackinac Center, the State Policy Network, Heritage on into the current Rick Snyder administration. Just one example:

    ALEC National Chairman Dick Posthumus 1993-1994

    This is Dick Posthumus, former Lt Gov under ALEC founding member Gov John Engler, appointed by Rick Snyder to be special adviser and legislative affairs liaison, one of several Michiganders that have been in national leadership roles in the American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC) in Michigan.

    Can’t wait for the rest of the story, this is just a few of the ALEC models recently appearing in Michigan, and only current members. Snyder has more ALEC folks in his ranks and has used ALEC content and strategies. That’s the story, but this a solid start, whoever did this did some good work.


  1. […] ALEC on BFM: Michigan Needs ALEC Accountability Act NOW (Bonus: Who is Richard McLellan?) – ALEC in Michigan: Full Report w/ Executive Summary by Progress Michigan, Common Cause, & Michiga… – Walmart Wants ‘Out’, Michigan Goes ‘All-In’ – Will Detroit 3 Dump ALEC Too? […]

Speak Your Mind